Are E-Collars Safe for Dogs?

Full name
June 6, 2023
5 min read
Share this post

Dog E-Collar Safety

The most effective way to answer the question regarding the safety of electronic collars (e-collars) is to think of things like this: simply put, e-collars are as safe as the dog owner or dog trainer who uses them.

When it comes to the safety of e-collars, you have to acknowledge that they only become dangerous when the intent behind their purpose (behavior modification) is abused. If the handler of the e-collar is educated on how to use the e-collar and is aware of how their dog responds to the different settings, then the experience will be highly effective and safe for the dog. With positive reinforcement training, unwanted behavior is replaced with desired behavior.

At Minnesota Canine Consulting, we are devoted and dedicated to the safe and responsible use of e-collars. Our dogs are our family and we believe yours are too. 

Keep reading to see how we address common myths around e-collars and safety.

Myth #1: E-collars make dogs aggressive

An e-collar is a piece of equipment – it’s an inanimate object. It’s the human component that links e-collars to words like danger and fear. In fact, when used with fidelity and experience, an e-collar can be a training option for some aggressive dogs. 

Dogs are responsive to their environments. A dog who is trained properly with an e-collar in a healthy and positive environment is a dog that will safely learn how to be responsive. 

Myth #2: E-collars are uncomfortable for dogs

Part of responsibly using e-collars as an effective dog training method is to understand how to best fit your dog with his or her e-collar. If your dog is fit with a collar that is too tight, then your buddy will be uncomfortable. Your dog will rely on you to find the e-collar that will allow for comfortable training. 

E-collars come in many different sizes with different capabilities so you are bound to find one that will comfortably fit your dog. Pay attention to your dog – you know them best! If their body language is telling you they are uncomfortable, take the time to adjust the collar size to set your dog up for success!

Myth #3: E-collars hurt dogs

E-collars omit a sensation for the dog that is comparable to what humans feel when they get a static shock from a dry environment. You can feel it but it’s not painful. It’s more surprising because it’s unexpected.

E-collar sensations have also been compared to the electric-stimulation treatment at a chiropractor. Again, you can feel a sensation, but that sensation does not hurt. 

Myth #4: E-collars make dogs afraid

E-collars are meant to be used by an educated human who is aware of the concepts of conditioning. Conditioning is how we learn a lot of our behaviors so it’s no wonder why it’s an effective teaching method for our dogs. 

Users who carefully condition their dogs to respond calmly upon e-collar activation are the users who teach their dogs to be calm and controlled in their environments. 

We also believe in incorporating positive reinforcement with e-collar training so your pooch can draw a connection between proper behavior and something desirable like a treat, a sweet tap or scratch on the head, or another reward. 

Conclusion - Are E-Collars Safe for Dogs?

It’s common to hear people love their dogs like family and, well, that’s because dogs have an innate ability to know how to love unconditionally. In return, dogs deserve to live a happy life, full of love where they feel confident and safe! 

An e-collar is a safe way for your dog to learn desirable behaviors. Honor your responsibility as an e-collar user so your dog receives the utmost in their training experience. 

Reach out to Minnesota Canine Consulting today to get answers and insight from our passionate and highly educated dog training professionals!


How do I know what kind of e-collar to use?

To pick the best e-collar, you need to keep a couple of things in mind like the size of your dog, your training goals, your desired stimulator type (tone, vibration, or pulse), and your connection range needs. Rest assured that e-collars come in many varieties so you will be able to find the right fit for your dog!

Do e-collars hurt my dog?

If you’ve ever been exposed to a stimulator treatment at your chiropractor, you can compare that experience to what dogs with an e-collar experience. A shock collar is a thing of the past and we are not fans of the harsh settings. An e-collar is not the same thing as a shock collar. 

How do e-collars work?

E-collars are electronic dog training aids. E-collars have a small electronic receiver attached to them. The collar must be properly fitted to your dog’s neck. The owner then uses a remote that speaks to the receiver attached to the collar. Upon the owner pressing the remote, the collar’s response system is activated and a tone, vibration, or pulsating physical signal will be given to your dog. When used consistently, dogs will learn the difference between good and bad behavior.

Share this post